He also befriends a fan, the young son of his housekeeper, who wants him to work again. In feature adaptation of bestselling book the secret. International sherlock holmes adaptations united states. Holmes is set in the aftermath of the second world war, starring sir ian mckellen who never disappoints and triumphs in the lead role, supported by a great ensemble cast. The stylistic similarities between condon and gilliam are few and far between, but both films do involve a child. And while many of the really famous sherlock holmes adaptations originate in the uk, theres a whole world out there that loves sherlock holmes just as much. Despite the characters nearubiquitous presence in other media and household recognition, in comic books sherlock holmes has. Based on the book by nicholas meyer, the sevenpercent solution 1976 takes the drug angle a step further by forcing holmes nicol. Holmes is 93 and struggles to set the record straight on his final case. The film is based on mitch cullins 2005 novel a slight trick of the mind. Holmes, the latest depiction of holmes, directed by bill condon and based on mitch cullins novel a slight trick of the mind, manages to find new ground by emphasizing the characters vulnerability and, thus, his humanity. The 2018 television adaptation, miss sherlock, is a.
The first two seasons of the bbcs modern sherlock holmes adaptation are near perfection, drawing on doyles original stories and faithfully updating them for the 21st century and its technological complications. With ian mckellen, laura linney, hiroyuki sanada, hattie morahan. Aug 09, 2017 the secret, which was on the nyts bestseller list for 3 12 years is coming to the big screen with katie holmes. Good morning, irene reissued as the adventuress 1991. So before you groan at the arrival of yet another celluloid adaptation, know that mr. My second favourite version of this story and peter cushings best performance as sherlock holmes. Katie holmes to star in feature adaptation of bestselling. Based on the novel a slight trick of the mind by mitch cullin who also cowrote the screenplay adaptation, mr. Watson and holmes watson and holmes recasts the title characters as african american men living in modernday harlem. Apr 22, 2015 there are currently two contemporary television properties sherlock, elementary and a feature film series starring robert downey, jr.
Val andrews sherlock holmes and the charlie chaplin mystery 1990, sherlock holmes and the eminent thespian 1988, sherlock holmes and the brighton pavilion mystery 1989, sherlock holmes and the egyptian hall adventure 1993, sherlock holmes and the houdini birthright 1995, sherlock holmes and the yuletide mystery 1996, sherlock holmes and the man who lost himself 1996, sherlock. Now he must quietly slip out of retirement and pay a secret visit to his past in order to determine the future, in this intriguing and thoughtful suspensethriller. Strange case of dr jekyll and mr hyde is a novella written by the scottish author robert louis stevenson and first published in 1886. Of course, being one the most popular characters in literary history, adapted hundreds of times for both the big screen and small and with the guinness book of records listing the supersleuth as the most portrayed movie character in history hes never really gone away. Jul 24, 2015 its 1947, and sherlock holmes is a 93 year old and retired in sussex. Evergreen supersleuth sherlock holmes gets the revisionist treatment once more in this beautifully crafted gem. In their first adventure, collected in watson and holmes. With over 250 holmes adaptations on screen alone according to guinness world records, this list could never be definitive. Holmes of diminished mind and body, the worlds greatest detective rallies to solve one last mystery in bill condons intimate, elegiac sherlock holmes tale.
Based on a childrens book series, sherlock yack is about sherlock yack, who is, well, a yak. A power ranking of sherlock holmes adaptations electric. Based on the book a slight trick of the mind by mitch cullin, the film stars sir ian. He is impressive to say the least and his onscreen chemistry with milo parker is a thing to behold. Jul 17, 2015 but mr holmes is a direct adaptation of a novel by a different author. For faithfulness to its source material and the spirit of the work, this adaptation is hard to beat. It does this to the point where we learn so much about mr holmes and probably ourselves. Holmes which is directed by kinsey and dreamgirls helmer bill condon. Based on a slight trick of the mind, a book from 2005 by mitch cullin, the plot follows a beaky ian mckellen as a senescent holmes during the winter of his life in postwar england. It is directed by oscar winner bill condon and stars ian mckellen as sherlock holmes and laura linney as his housekeeper, mrs munro each actors second collaboration with condon, after 1998s gods and monsters and 2004s kinsey, respectively. Holmes is a mystery drama based on the novel a slight trick of the mind by mitch cullin, directed by bill condon the twilight saga. Munro laura linney and her young son roger milo parker and the incomplete memory of the case that drove him into retirement.
The work is known for its vivid portrayal of a split personality, and since the 1880s dozens of stage and film adaptations. The fourvolumes of the universal sherlock holmes 1995 compiled by ronald b. Holmes lives in a sussex farm house and has spent decades in content isolation, tending to his gardens and his apiary. Though its central mystery isnt from the doyle canon, mr. Holmes is a film that can stand on its own and provides that rare quality in a sherlock holmes adaptation. A mostly definitive ranking of sherlock holmes adaptations. But heres a start of the best in tv and movie adaptations. The same can be said of the subsequent the return of sherlock holmes, the casebook of sherlock holmes, and the memoirs of sherlock holmes, each of which showcases bretts studied holmesian brilliance. The first part of this book was an excellent read and put meat into the character portrayed in the movie. The full trailer for upcoming big screen sherlock holmes saga mr. As a bonus, the foley work and sound engineering of these adaptations have a hypnotic asmr crispness. Jul 26, 2018 sherlock holmes has been around for 1 years and has had at least as many adaptations. Holmes, of sherlock fame, has one last case to solve at the ripe old age of 93.
Jun 15, 2015 so before you groan at the arrival of yet another celluloid adaptation, know that mr. He runs a zoo and, with the help of a weasel named. The stylistic similarities between condon and gilliam are few and far between, but both films do involve a child fascinated by a world of fantasy. An aged, retired sherlock holmes deals with early dementia, as he tries to remember his final case, and a mysterious woman, whose memory haunts him. Holmes ages an iconic hero to give him new life popoptiq. Sherlock holmes goodreads meet your next favorite book. He lives near the sea, hes got his bees, and hes not as sharp as he used to be. The stories of sherlock holmes by sir arthur conan doyle were very popular as adaptations for the stage, and later film, and still later television. The mystery of the manor house 1982, the baker street boys 1983, the sign of four 1983, the hound of the baskervilles 1983, sherlock holmes 1984. A power ranking of sherlock holmes adaptations electric literature. The novel is written in a manner that suggests it was essentially taking place behind the scenes of the familiar.
Mitch cullin made a major mistake by killing off the character of roger and in my opinion ruined the story. Rupert holmes talks about writing the script for the new john kander and fred ebb musical curtains after the deaths of peter stone, the first writer, and mr. Many authors tried to fulfill this needs and a lot of pastiches, parodies and adaptations were produced until today, reaching from book form, movies, tv series, over. Holmes, a smart, wonderfully nuanced adaptation directed by bill condon that stars sir ian mckellen and laura linney. The same can be said of the subsequent the return of sherlock holmes, the case book of sherlock holmes, and the memoirs of sherlock holmes, each of which showcases bretts studied holmesian brilliance. A study in black, holmes and watson meet at the emergency medical clinic where watson works and team up to solve a kidnapping. Holmes which is directed by kinsey and dreamgirls helmer bill condon features a version of sherlock thats unlike any that has gone before. Bill condon was set to direct jeffrey hatchers adaptation of the novel. The mystery of the manor house 1982, the baker street boys 1983, the sign of four 1983, the hound of the baskervilles 1983, sherlock holmes. Watson wrote about their work together and it disturbed him for several reasons, not the least of which was that he could no longer remember the particulars of the case from 35 years. Holmes, which is an adaptation of mitch cullins book a slight trick of the mind, mckellen is playing a fictional character the uncannily gifted detective sherlock holmes but the. Tv series, mini series, tv movies, short videos or documentaries adaptations of sherlock holmes. But mr holmes is a direct adaptation of a novel by a different author. Holmes, but this insignificant subplot pushes things a little too far.
Sherlock holmes is a fictional private detective created by british. The 10 best sherlock holmes adaptations, according to. In the 1990s, caliber comics issued a fourpart sherlock holmes reader which features quotes from holmes, a map of 221b baker street, and canon story adaptations as well as individual stories such as dr. Ian mckellen plays an aged holmes past his mental prime, struggling against encroaching senility to remember the conclusion to his final mystery.
Set primarily during his retirement in sussex, the film follows a 93yearold holmes who struggles to. Billy wilders utterly bizarre the private life of sherlock holmes 1970, for instance, is equally deserving of a mention. This summer will see the release of mr holmes in cinemas. The man who disappeared 1951, the adventures of sherlock holmes 1954, sherlock holmes 19651968, the hound of the baskervilles 1971, sherlock holmes and doctor watson 1980, young sherlock. Sherlock holmes and the case of too many adaptations quirk. The film is an adaptation of a mitch cullin book, depicting holmes in his 90s. A mostly definitive ranking of sherlock holmes adaptations book. It is about a london lawyer who investigates strange occurrences between his old friend, dr. They include the original writings, together with the translations of these tales into sixtythree. No doubt it works well in the book, but it would have been better left on the cutting room floor for the purposes of adaptation. And going to the movies to see an adaptation of watsons. The last time he was in london, to take care of the possessions of his recently deceased brother, mycroft, mr.
Holmes isnt another fastpaced adaptation of the character that popculture has become used to recently, but a quiet character piece that is radical in its introduction of a revisionist. Holmes is very much a fallen idol, aged 93 and long living in relative anonymity in a sussex farm house, far from the prying eyes of the fans who once crowded the entrance to his baker street home, spurred on by the fictionalized holmes tales published by his erstwhile partner, dr. With more than 250 sherlock holmes adaptations, theres no way to rank them all. There are some differences in the story, particularly in the fate of the young boy that holmes is teaching about bees and their habits. Kings the beekeepers apprentice mystery novels, takes place in his later years after his retirement. Holmes is very much a fallen idol, aged 93 and long living in relative anonymity in a sussex farm house, far from the prying eyes of the fans who once. Bfi players japan 2020 season is now live, featuring an akira kurosawa collection. Since the episode the mazarin stone of the jeremy brett sherlock holmes series is an adaptation of two stories theres one space on this this list for a double entry. Holmes is still a literary adaptation, based on the novel a slight trick of the mind by mitch cullin, who also wrote the book that became terry gilliams film tideland. Holmes gifts us with one of sir ian mckellens finest performances to date. Holmes has arrived and, while it represents at least the fourth mainstream portrayal of the great detective to grace popular culture in the past five years, it seems safe to say that this film is doing its best to set itself apart as something different based on the novel a slight trick of the mind by mitch cullin, the film. As in cullins book where the glass armonicist became a fullfledged novellawithinthenovel, complete with its own title page and chapter headings, the nesting of stories within stories creates a nifty hallofmirrors effect, climaxing in holmes visit to a cinema screening a film adaptation of the armonica case, based on watson.
In a slight trick of the mind, we are treated to the premise that sherlock holmes was an actual living historical figure. The secret, which was on the nyts bestseller list for 3 12 years is coming to the big screen with katie holmes. Rise of an empire 50 first dates 5050 a beautiful mind a cinderella story a clockwork orange a few good men a knights tale a lot like love a separation a streetcar named desire a walk to remember about time adaptation. Mr holmes is the film adaptation of mitch cullins book, a slight trick of the mind. Estleman, is a retelling of the story based on the idea that utterson hired sherlock holmes to investigate hydes connection to jekyll in the belief that hyde is a blackmailer. Really old in fact, with this take on the character 93 and retired to a cottage in the sussex countryside to live in anonymity and. Jun 15, 2015 sherlock holmes has been undergoing something of a renaissance over the last few years. Holmes which is directed by kinsey and dreamgirls helmer bill condon features a version of sherlock. When i came to write the unlikely escape of uriah heep, a book peopled with famous literary characters, i was very excited to create my own. The book, published in 2005, was lauded for how it humanized holmes, allowing. It is hard to imagine another film digging deeper into the implications of holmes as a reasoning machine or turning him so effectively into a hall of mirrors. Holmes is in theatres now and you can find tickets us at fandango and moviefone. The adventures of sherlock holmes book cover picture. Mr holmes is set in the 1940s, holmes is in his 90s and his health and memory is failing him.
962 1215 909 223 1389 1003 768 1268 462 1316 198 936 641 1182 149 821 721 665 1117 950 1517 1252 1393 583 1168 1435 720 771 1133 515 1142 619 643 1227 134 1128 1382 1075 404 347 1215 1459 799 1097 1051 540 468 1053 824